Washington and the Whiskey Rebellion
This lesson plan examines a critical episode in George Washington's second administration, when federal efforts to collect an excise tax on liquor sparked armed resistance in the frontier communities of western Pennsylvania. Students first review the events that led up to this confrontation, then read from the diary that Washington kept as he gathered troops to put down the insurrection. Focusing on Washington's account of a meeting midway on his march, with spokespersons for the rebels, students outline the arguments on both sides and explore the risks and benefits of the options Washington had before him: whether to uphold the law with military force or withdraw and let the already-waning rebellion sputter out. After debating this choice, students consider the political climate of the times, as reflected in the message Washington delivered to Congress upon his return from the frontier, and consider how far Washington's actions in the Whiskey Rebellion crisis were motivated by politics rather than principle. Finally, students return to the central issue raised by the Whiskey Rebellion to compare Washington's decision with the those of later presidents who faced this same question of constitutional authority: When is the federal government justified in using force against American citizens?
No guiding questions
To learn about the Whiskey Rebellion of 1794 and its significance in the early history of the United States
To explore how George Washington made the choice to meet this challenge to federal authority with military force
To evaluate the extent to which political pressures may have influenced Washington's decision
To weigh the merit of Washington's policy in light of more recent challenges to federal authority
To gain experience in working with private diaries, letters, and public speeches as resources for historical study.